Karachi or New York, basic rights like food, clothing, and shelter matter for everyone, says Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.
PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari congratulated Zohran Mamdani on becoming New York’s first Muslim mayor. However, his message linking New Yorkers to Karachi residents and praising democracy has sparked criticism on social media.
Bilawal tweeted, “Zohran Mamdani’s victory proves that basic rights like food, clothing, and shelter are universal, whether in Karachi or New York.” He added that a South Asian candidate winning on a progressive platform in a global city brings hope worldwide.
Mamdani, a Democratic Socialist, made history as New York’s youngest mayor, promising to curb rent hikes, introduce free public bus services, and set up city-run grocery stores—moves that won him strong support from progressive voters.
While Bilawal praised Mamdani’s vision, social media users questioned whether PPP remains truly progressive. Ali Aon Wasi wrote, “Your party’s policies no longer appear people-friendly or progressive. There’s still time for reflection before the damage becomes permanent.”
PTI leader Tayyaba Raja criticized Bilawal, saying, “Your mother’s soul must shudder seeing your statements and actions contradict each other.”
Other social media users also reacted sharply: Jibran Nasir commented, “Your party has failed,” slamming Bilawal for comparing Mamdani’s win to PPP’s legacy. Another user added, “Your party’s policies no longer appear people‑friendly or progressive. There’s still time for reflection before the damage becomes permanent.”
This comes amid debates over Pakistan’s 27th constitutional amendment, with Bilawal claiming the federal government sought PPP’s support. Social media user Abdullah Imran criticized PPP’s stance, noting that the party supported the 26th amendment and is now backing the 27th, questioning its progressive image.
The 26th constitutional amendment had been passed in October 2024 with a two-thirds majority, fully supported by PPP.